instead of writing miles of text and forcing other ppl to read it try understanding, that you are writing with fork on the surface of water. you try to base your theory on ratio 1 x 1. i told its wrong since its more complicated. and gave hypothetical example according to my experience in other games where formulas are involved. i didnt say its correct. just some material ppl to think about before thinking plain "you got 10 aim and i have 20 dodge, so my dodge negates your aim"