Granted, as in any random situation, there will be people who win most of the time and those that lose most of the time. Maybe I'm just one of the unlucky ones this time. It won't be making any new friends for Inno though. Those who win most of the time will expect it, and those who mostly lose will be upset.
I would be curious if most of the losers have a charisma build since other builds have a distinct advantage over charisma in dueling a mirror opponent. A person with 100 charisma who uses 40 appearance in their clothes will have only 140-100 advantage over the NPC because they give away 100 tactics, whereas any other builds with same clothes would have a 40-0 advantage, and win a lot more. Sad if they have made a "free" giveaway that penalizes a certain build.