Ive been playing this game for about 2 weeks now. Im constantly learning as much as i can from both visiting the forums often as well as speaking with people who have been around since w1 and still play in about 10 of them. I have learned a great deal from the forums, but even more from the people experienced in this game. I learn things in game that the mods seem clueless about, which is often confusing to me. I can only come up with theories as to why mods never really seem to answer a question. It seems as if they are, but they never really do. Anyhow, im a noob, but one thing i have noticed when it comes to dodging is that it only really applies to your stances. The chance of being hit, depending on what stance you are in, is lowered by a higher skill lvl of dodge. I cant speak accurately on much else, but this is something that has proven to be true in my experiences. I've met alot of morons that have played all worlds, so dont let that fool you.
And btw, why are you trying to reconstruct a duel with only those stats? No one is going to hit each other, they will both stand there slapping at the air. If you want to stay on point, dont try to create a duel out of it.