Well, as Neo-quick and Elmyr have said, no one could really answer this question, because it's based on luck.
er.. that IS an answer. i found those 50 responses saying the same "not enough details" annoyingly asinine.. if you still need more details.. fine: the sun is about 5º above the horizon, the defender is wearing red lipstick and the attacker is wearing his lucky blue shoelaces (+1% chance to not bore me to death). and all other pointless information is 42.
you have 60 aim 60 dodge vs 60 aim 60 tactics, simply assume all else equal and gear and all those lovely other variables everyone keeps clamoring about become irrelevant..
obviously the point is to ask whether dodge alone is better than tactics alone. most people who actually bothered answering the question seem to think/agree dodge is the better.
also i'll add that even if dodging and tactics are of similar value, it should be more efficient to put more into dodge since tactics is used only in defense while dodge is used in both. however without knowing the exact duel formulas used one can only speculate as to how useful each skill is. and really there could be a cap in play against the skills so that adding too much of one without any of the other wont be of any help.
in other words, its hard to definitively tell which is better, but i'd guess dodge, but due to the unknown formula would add that it might be wise to put a few points into tactics anyway (and appearance if you're at all interested in attacking).
and yes, part of the answer is that there is an element of luck involved, since you're talking about
chances to hit and
chances to miss.
so yes whoever said the attacker
could miss 8 times and the defender
could hit 8 times is correct, its just
very unlikely, but duel a couple billion times and it
could happen..
Meanwhile, the attacker has only 5 Aim, and the defender has 5 dodging, which means a small interval (only 1~5).
sorry but did you even bother to read the original post? the attacker has 60 aim, how did he end up with 5? 60 tactics is supposed to cancel out 60 aim?