Amerigo Vespucci vs. Richard Amerike

Discussion in 'Debate and discussion' started by oisinallen, Jul 10, 2009.

Share This Page

  1. oisinallen

    oisinallen Guest

    A lot of people believe that America was named after Italian cartographer and explorer Amerigo Vespucci.

    However, in 1479 (13 years before Columbus' first voyage), Richard Amerike (pronounced "America") sponsored John Cabot's voyage to Newfoundland. Columbus knew about the British discoveries in Newfoundland before he sailed.

    Therefore, many people believe that America was named after Richard Amerike. One of the arguments for Amerike is that he was very important in terms of its discovery.

    Another is that when a place is named after a real person, (eg. James Cook & the Cook Islands; but not Europa & Europe) it is named after their surname (unless they are royalty, because a lot of royals are of the same family, and have the same surname).

    Amerike-supporters have said that if America was named after Amerigo Vespucci, it should be called Vespuccia.

    However, the Vespucci-supporters have pointed out that all of the continents have Latin female names. America is the Latin female version of Amerigo (which is an Italian male name). Amerike is a Welsh surname.

    This resulted in the Amerike-supporters saying that the other continents have not been named after real people, and naming America after a real person would mess up the naming system, so it may not be true.

    So what do you think? Who is America named after? Do you have any other evidence for either side? Do you think it was named after someone completely different?
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jul 10, 2009
  2. Hellstromm

    Hellstromm Guest

    It's actually not called America, it's called Hellstromma
     
  3. Toko22

    Toko22 Guest

    Elmyr is never wrong, so I'll go with Amerigo!!!
     
  4. I really am not too sure about the whole thing, really, Im thinking more on Amerigo, but then again, that sounds more like an Oil company... Amerike is the same.

    I'd have to say Amerigo, simply because more Oil companies have the word "Go" and the english word "Go" means... well... "GO!" as in Move forward, many Americans want to move forward, as in "GO!" so AmeriGO! Vespucchia is probably the one.

    I vote Amerigo Vespucchia
     
  5. johannmaximus

    johannmaximus Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    May 9, 2009
    Messages:
    2,868
    Likes Received:
    269
    I'd say America is named from a hat of names people picked, and has nothing to do with either one of them, so I vote:

    The Hat
     
  6. iggyberto

    iggyberto Guest

    America is named after Amerigo because he made the map and therefore named it.
     
  7. Betsy

    Betsy Guest

    We Canadians know, thanks to those wonderful Heritage minutes, that Canada is derived from the Cree word "Kanata", meaning "village" or "gathering place".

    So, I'm going to say that America is actually derived from the Algonquian "ammerkeu", meaning "go home now" or "&*#^*", depending on context. We'll never really know, though, since Algonquian is a lost language.

    p.s.;)

     
  8. oisinallen

    oisinallen Guest

    Sorry, but an older map which names America as America was made by the German cartographer Martin Waldseemuller. He may have named America, or he may have got the name from another place. Either way, he supported Vespucci - he even though Vespucci had discovered America!

    Algonquian is a language family, but there is a language called Algonquin (I get them confused all the time, too). And over 2,000 people still speak Algonquin.
     
  9. Betsy

    Betsy Guest


    I am not, by any means, an orthographic expert. So, I browsed wiki http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algonquian_languages.

    p.s. did you see my previous p.s.?
     
  10. fergenburger

    fergenburger Guest

    Amerigo sounds more like a ride for children than someone who a mighty country was named after. i reckon amerike!!
     
  11. scwanobi

    scwanobi Guest

    I think it went down like this. After leif ericson discovered america he decided to name it after himself but wasn't very clear. He said, "um eric ah yeah, lets go with that."
     
  12. johannmaximus

    johannmaximus Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    May 9, 2009
    Messages:
    2,868
    Likes Received:
    269
    That's funny scwanobi. I'm still going with my hat theory.