Seems like they are starting to forget they came from Wanted, all of them, so wow, that was really "hard" to fill up a town with the highest levels they had in all 6 wanted towns.
They also seem to forget Wanted was going down ... losing it's forts, losing it's members, losing it's power.
And oh yeah, they won a battle with the Easter quests around. Battles and duels are not everything for Gunslingers Gulch. We hunt eggs and tend sheep for the little fun of making a quest. So yeah, a "great success" on your part.
And what about those duels? What about the lost duels? What about the passed out members? Aaaa it counts only to see the beautiful part of it, I get it. This is the only way you can keep your morale up. I'll be quiet, not nice of me to spoil your illusions.