You are right!!! I have the thief quest under the completed quests, but this is so weird?! I don't remember completing that quest (which is ok, because I do many quests and it's impossible to remember every one of them), but what is strange is that I can't recall to ever give away my weapon to defeat the thief and have 200$ on me. All is solved for me now, I already completed other 3 quests and just figured that I completed the thief one too, so I don't need to wait for it anymore. Thanks everyone that helped me figure this out! Syntax I hope you will figure it out too.