DeletedUser
Hmm, Politifact provides a clearer picture of promises kept and broken, which firmly debunks your 50/50 claim:Obama actually has been about 50/50 with the promises he made while campaigning, he has just been failing with the choices of which promises to keep, in my opinion.
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/obameter/
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/gop-pledge-o-meter/
Now, it must be said the GOP provided only 57 promises since 2010, as compared to Obama's 508 promises since 2008. Obama provided almost 10 times more promises than the GOP. Now, let's review the numbers, rather than merely the misleading tactic of arguing percentages:
Promises Kept: GOP = 10 vs Obama = 182. A 1:18 ratio.
Not that good for GOP, with only one kept promise for every 18 promises kept by Obama.
Promises In the Works: GOP = 14 vs Obama = 134. A 2:19 ratio.
Still not that good for GOP, with only two promises in the works for every 19 promises in the works by Obama.
Not that good for GOP, with only one kept promise for every 18 promises kept by Obama.
Promises In the Works: GOP = 14 vs Obama = 134. A 2:19 ratio.
Still not that good for GOP, with only two promises in the works for every 19 promises in the works by Obama.
Let's add an additional bit of information: The GOP being considered in these promises, consists of all the GOP Representatives and Senators in Congress, as opposed to One man in the White House. Not only is that so few promises for so many, but so poor a track record considering they control the House of Representatives and have swing capacity in the Senate.
And now let's demonstrate how Obama has "worked" with the GOP, through presentation of compromises:
Compromises: GOP = 1 vs Obama = 58. A surprising 1:58 ratio.
Yes, Obama compromised on 58 of his promises, to get things addressed and passed through a hostile Congress, as opposed to the GOP compromising only once. And what did the GOP compromise on? Webcasting of committee meetings. They are now webcast, but no transcript is provided. I hardly call that a compromise.
Yes, Obama compromised on 58 of his promises, to get things addressed and passed through a hostile Congress, as opposed to the GOP compromising only once. And what did the GOP compromise on? Webcasting of committee meetings. They are now webcast, but no transcript is provided. I hardly call that a compromise.
Now for the broken: Promises broken by GOP = 2, vs Obama = 69. That's a heartbreak to Democrats, no doubt, but then we examine one of the two promises broken by the GOP --- "Will not bundle bills into 'must-pass' legislation." This broken promise is exactly what I was referring to in my earlier post <click here>, in which the GOP repeatedly (and still) bundles bills into 'must-pass' legislation, thus resulting in promises broken by Obama specifically BECAUSE the GOP directly caused such promises to be broken (such as the continuation of Bush's wealthy tax cut, which was bundled with necessary employment/unemployment funding bills).
These are the core issues here on the reasons why many promises have not been fulfilled by Obama --- GOP obstructionism and national sabotage through political shenanigans (record filibusters, bill bundling, etc). Thus, while it is correct to recognize Obama for his accomplishments (182 kept, 58 compromises, 134 in the works = 74%) it is grossly improper to argue Obama's fail promise ledger is due to Obama, as it is instead largely due to probably the worst run of GOP officials to hit Congress since the Civil War (do consider GOP Congressional record-low disapproval ratings, so this isn't merely my personal opinion). Indeed, 63 of Obama's promises are presently being stalled, almost exclusively by the GOP, in Congress. Compare this to only 5 GOP promises stalled, two of which are due to no actions committed by the GOP to address them (i.e., no bills or proposals).
I would like to close by pointing out, despite the record number of GOP filibusters, the GOP bundling of bills into 'must pass' legislation, and the corporate-backed smear campaign (inclusive of FOX news' four minute anti-Obama ad), it is incredible Obama has been able to fulfill 182 promises (plus compromised on 58 promises, thus having successfully addressed 240 promises, and don't forget the additional 134 still in the works). It is indisputable, 182 fulfilled promises is more than ANY U.S. President in history during their 1st term in office.
Hard facts to swallow, I'm sure.
Last edited by a moderator: